File a Claim/Make a Payment Auto Owners Claim # 888-252-4626 Billing # 800-288-8740 Pay Online Foremost Claim # 800-435-7764 Billing # 800-532-4221 Pay Online Lititz Mutual Claim # 800-621-3991 Billing # 800-626-4751 Pay Online Progressive Claim # 800-776-4737 Billing # 800-876-5581 Pay Online Safeco Claim # 800-332-3226 Billing # 800-332-3226 Pay Online State Auto Claim # 800-766-1853 Billing # 800-444-9950 X-5118 Pay Online Travelers Claim # 800-252-4633 Billing # 800-550-7716 Pay Online Resource Menu File a Claim/Make a Payment Certificate of Insurance Request Form Add/Remove a Driver Add/Remove Vehicle to Auto Policy Address Change Refer a Friend Auto I.D. Card Request Form FAQ’s